Is Hanukkah the Jewish equivalent to Christmas?
1. Chanukah is not the Jewish Christmas.
While
Chanukah and Christmas both occur near the end of the secular year, and
center around lights during the darkest, longest nights of our year,
despite these outward similarities, the two are vastly different in
religious meaning.
Hanukkah became popular in the U.S. because of its
calendar proximity to Christmas, but this Jewish holiday has a religious
meaning not even close to the Christian meaning and celebration of
Christmas.
Chanukah is, in fact, the celebration of the first successful
battle for freedom of religion. To consider Chanukah as a “Jewish
Christmas” of sorts is to allow the Christian celebration of Christmas
to overshadow and strip away the real meaning of an authentically Jewish
Chanukah celebration.
2. Gift giving was never a part of Hanukkah observance.
This
has been added in over recent years here in the United States due to
the overbearing emphasis of the Christian Christmas celebration
throughout all facets of American society. While some Jewish families
have developed a ritual of lighting candles and giving gifts over the 8
nights of Chanukah observance, other families replace eight nights of
gift giving with a mix of learning, social action, and giving, and many
Jewish families do not observe any form of Chanukah at all.
There is no
such thing as a “Chanukah Bush” that substitutes for a Christmas tree.
While some Jewish families may choose to do this, is it NOT part of an
authentic Jewish tradition. It is simply what some Jewish families
choose to do here in the United States. Treating Chanukah like a “Jewish
Christmas equivalent” buries a unique Jewish freedom celebration under
layers of consumeristic-driven gift giving. The real gift of Chanukah
was the gift of religious freedom, something for which so many still
fight around the world.
3. The Hanukkah candelabra is known as a hanukkiyah, not a menorah.
The
menorah is a candelabra which holds 7 candles that stood in the
Jerusalem Temple. It became a symbol of Judaism and is carved into one
of the gates of Rome. The hanukkiyah, in contrast, has nine candles. One
candle is typically in the center, set apart from the other 8, and
known as the shamash, or “helper” candle. Its function is to light the
other eight candles. We light the candles from left to right, but add
candles each evening from right to left.
4. The custom of playing
with a dreidel (spinning top) is based on a German game, and came about
during a time when being Jewish was outlawed.
While it looked like a
common gambling game to others, it was a Jewish teaching game so that
parents could quietly pass on Jewish values to their children without
being imprisoned for doing so. The dreidl has continued to be a symbol
of religious freedom.
5. The traditional Hanukkah foods are potato pancakes (latkes) and jelly donuts (sufganiyot).
Both
foods involve frying and oil. Oil symbolizes the miracle of Hanukkah.
According to Jewish tradition, the Maccabees found a tin of oil in the
Temple after they recaptured it. Containing only enough oil to provide
light for one night, it miraculously lasted for eight nights. And that
is referred to as “the miracle of Chanukah.”
6. There is no one right away to spell Hanukkah.
Most
commonly it is spelled either Chanukah or Hanukkah. Both are used
interchangeably. Both are correct, since there is no single direct way
to spell Hebrew words in English. Both have 8 letters to honor the 8
nights of Chanukah.
Finally, many have asked what Chanukah means to me personally, and so I offer this brief reflection:
Chanukah
is a celebration of finding the light in the darkest time. It is not
enough to encounter the darkness. Our mission is to find the light. I am
always struck by the story of the Maccabee’s discovery of a single jug
of pure olive oil suitable to light the Temple’s menorah.
There
they were amidst a completely ransacked and totally desecrated Temple.
The place of greatest holiness and connection had been made a shambles,
and the worst things imaginable had been done on its altars by those who
defeated the Jews and ran them our of their Temple, their country, and
barred them from observing their religion.
In similar fashion, I
imagine the scenes of Kristallnacht, in Germany, that dreadful night,
known as the Night of Shattered Glass. On November 9 to November 10,
1938, Nazis in Germany torched synagogues, vandalized Jewish homes,
schools and businesses, and killed close to 100 Jews for no other reason
than that they were Jews.
And how did the Jewish people respond? When
the killing and violence was over and the Nazis stopped long enough to
take a breath, the remaining Jewish community gathered around the
shattered glass of who they had been, and they lit the menorah. There
was no knowing what tomorrow would bring (and things only got worse from
there). But in that moment they found the hope and determination to
continue on, to affirm light and life. That is miraculous.
We
don’t just show up to the darkness, we find reason for hope and praise.
In describing the inspiration for creating the song “Hallelujah,”
Leonard Cohen, who recently died, said, “I wanted to stand with those
who clearly see G!d’s holy broken world for what it is, and still find
the courage or the heart to praise it.”
In a time of deep
darkness and confusion, it is easy to run away. But there is a light
that is calling to us. It starts with saying, “Here I am.” But that is
only the beginning. We all have our own “single jug of pure olive oil.”
The place in ourselves where we hold our light of being, and when we
fall short of enough love, energy, or hope, that’s when we need to find
the courage to keep on going, to find a cause to praise. It’s not about
denying the difficulties; it’s about discovering goodness hiding in
their wake.
Chanukah, for me, is lighting my candle in the
darkness of a world so broken, so in need of healing. It is the
celebration that no matter how dark it may get, it only takes one person
standing up and lighting their candle, reminding the world that what
matters most is being the light.
For this reason, I do not
give Chanukah gifts. Hanukkah, for me, is a moving spiritual time of
deep prayer and reflection, of finding again the light within myself in
the midst of darkness and shattered glass.
It's a most wonderful time of year!
As we head into a time of year which has historically been a severe challenge for me to get through, I can honestly say that this year, I am...
-
Sermon preached at Emerson Chapel, December 6, 2016 Good morning! K and S were scheduled to present another discernment process to...
-
What is a "Community Rabbi"? Community Rabbi available for coffee and conversation This term is coming more into common usag...
-
There is something strongly on my mind today that I'd like to talk about. It's called voluntolding aka mandateering . Few of us ...

No comments:
Post a Comment